Blind Tasting Review of our top 6 review #0024

Who makes it? Chattanooga Whiskey, Hillrock Estates Distiller, Missouri Spirits Distillery(out of business) and Iron Smoke Distillery

This is our 2 year anniversary and we decided to do a blind tasting of our top 6 reviews.

The line up

  1. Joseph Magnus Cigar Blend
  2. Chattanooga Whiskey Straight 91
  3. Missouri Spirits
  4. Chattanooga Whiskey Straight 111
  5. Hillrock Solera Aged Bourbon
  6. Iron Smoke Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Off the get go Kris knew that number 1 was Joseph Magnus, with that heat and complexity it had to be. Erik on the other hand thought it might be Chatt 111. Kris went through and tasted them all first while Erik did a taste and put it on paper.

We talk about what we have learned of the past 2 years, where Kris thinks that finishing plays a very important role and Erik thinks we’ve come along way on nosing and relating the flavors on the finish. Since were talking about the best we decided to which was our least, for Kris, Maker’s Mark didn’t register high on his list while Erik gives Wild Turkey Rare Breed a hard NO and would love to do a “Rare Breed Sucks change my mind”(borrowed from Louder with Crowder) episode, coming to college near you. Erik races ahead and decides to give them all a shooting score to and 111 and Jos A Magnus almost take him out. An OG #whiskeykrew member Gary Elmes drops by and helps set up the tasting to keep it fair but there is one thing he won’t do on camera…

Kris’ list was:
Chatt 111
Chatt 91
Hillrock
Missouri Spirits
Iron Smoke
*Joseph Magnus Cigar Blend

Erik’s list was:
Hillrock
Chatt 91
Missouri
Chatt 111
Iron Smoke
Jos. Magnus CB

Shooting Score:
Missouri
Chatt 91
Iron Smoke
Hillrock
Chatt 111
Jos. Magnus CB